A federal judge has canceled a scheduled hearing for Dr. Rasha Alawieh, a physician from Brown University, following her recent deportation to Lebanon. This decision raised concerns regarding the adherence of U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) to the judge’s order, which aimed to maintain Alawieh’s presence in the country while her legal challenges regarding deportation were underway.

Background on Dr. Alawieh’s Case

Dr. Alawieh, a transplant nephrology specialist and assistant professor at Brown University, was detained after returning from Lebanon, where she had visited family. Upon her arrival at Boston’s Logan Airport, issues arose regarding her immigration status.

Judge Leo Sorokin issued a directive for Alawieh to be retained within the U.S. for a hearing scheduled for Monday. However, by the time CBP received the order, Alawieh had already left the country, as stated in a brief order released by the judge.

Government’s Stance and Legal Proceedings

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) confirmed that Alawieh informed CBP officers she had traveled to Beirut for a family funeral. The DHS emphasized the necessity of ensuring national security, stating, “A visa is a privilege not a right—glorifying and supporting terrorists who kill Americans is grounds for visa issuance to be denied.”

Evidence submitted by the government indicated that Alawieh was questioned about photographs on her phone that allegedly featured Hezbollah fighters. She reportedly explained that these images were shared within WhatsApp groups among friends and relatives.

In legal responses, Alawieh’s family alleged that the government had intentionally disregarded the judge’s ruling by deporting her. They sought clarification from the government to understand why she was removed from the United States.

Judge’s Assessment

Although the hearing was canceled, Judge Sorokin noted that an affidavit from a CBP watch commander confirmed the agency’s commitment to comply with court directives. The judge reiterated that no agency would neglect to take a court order seriously.

Dr. Alawieh has been residing in the U.S. on an H-1B visa since 2018, engaging in critical patient care related to kidney transplants, making her deportation a significant concern for both her family and colleagues.

Implications of Immigration Practices

This incident occurs against the backdrop of heightened immigration enforcement under previous administrations, particularly regarding visa holders affiliated with universities. Observers have noted the increasing scrutiny on scholars and professionals who may have ties to perceived threats.

In response to media inquiries, CBP reiterated its procedures for determining admissibility, asserting its role in safeguarding the nation while upholding the law.